Vital Football

Latest Liverpool FC News

Liverpool: Comolli Defends Transfer Record

Liverpool: Comolli Defends Transfer Record

Former Liverpool director of football Damien Comolli has defended his time at Anfield and feels he has unfinished business with the club...

Ex-Reds employee Damien Comolli has issued an outspoken justification of his record concerning player transfers whilst at Liverpool.

The Frenchman, sacked from the post of director of football in April, has been widely blamed for a number of expensive and unsuccessful recent signings including Andy Carroll, Stewart Downing and Jordan Henderson.

The three signings alone cost over £70m and heavily contributed to the total outlay of around £113million that the club spent on nine new players during Comolli's 17 months of negotiating deals.

Comolli however feels it is wrong to look at the players purchased in isolation and believes the money recouped from sales and a reduction of the club's wage bill should also be considered in any analysis.

"First of all you need to look at the big picture," explained the 40-year-old to the Daily Express. "We did 26 deals, and to think we would not make any mistakes in such a huge number of deals in and out would be totally unrealistic.

"I don't think we made any mistakes on the players going out, and whether we made mistakes on the players who came in I think, first of all, time will tell. I am very uncomfortable for players to be judged after six, eight or even 12 months."

In relation to the much-maligned club record signing of Andy Carroll for £35m, Comolli refused to acknowledge it was a mistake and even revealed he warned owners Fenway Sports Group (FSG) of the risks.

"If you want to talk about the Carroll deal, the situation was quite clear," said Comolli of a player now on loan at West Ham United.

"The way we looked at it, we were selling two players - Fernando Torres and Ryan Babel - and we were bringing two in - Luis Suarez and Carroll - and we were making a profit and the wage bill was coming down considerably as well. It was a four-player deal.

"Chelsea kept bidding higher and higher for Torres. The difference between their first and final bid is double.

"They (FSG) asked me what the risks were and I said if things don't go well you'll lose something on Andy, but it is difficult to measure whether you will make money if things go well because Liverpool aren't a selling club and he could be here for the next 10 years."

Liverpool's manager at the time, Kenny Dalglish, also followed Comolli out of the exit door during the summer despite reaching both domestic cup finals last season and winning one.

Commenting on a period in March when he stayed with the club's principle owner John Henry and chairman Tom Werner, Comolli revealed he told the pair to keep Dalglish in charge.

"Tom Werner said, 'Do you think Kenny is the right person?' I said, 'Definitely.' John Henry agreed with me. Kenny deserved longer and I told that to the owners many times. I never felt it (sacking him) was the right thing.

"The big turning point was the game against Arsenal the week after we won the Carling Cup. If we could win, anything would be possible. We missed a penalty and lost in injury time.

"But you were still looking at progress. Getting a trophy in year one, getting to the FA Cup Final, I think financially we were in a very good position. We managed to lower the wage bill a lot. The owners were delighted with that.

"I still struggle to watch Liverpool. I'm p***ed off, frustrated and annoyed because there is unfinished business."

The former Arsenal and Tottenham Hotspur scout has remained out of work since departing Merseyside but did recently win a wrongful dismissal case against his former employers. A court hearing in October saw a severance package agreed by both parties.

Vital Verdict
It is very hard to defend any of the prices paid for players during Comolli's period in charge of the club coffers. I do have some sympathy over the Carroll deal as Torres' decision to leave forced our hand at a very late stage of the transfer window. The move clearly hasn't worked out of course but that can happen regardless of the quality of player or the cost involved. The price paid for the likes of Downing and Henderson cannot be so readily explained however and the outlandish spending during this period is probably largely responsible for the owners' decision not to give new man Brendan Rodgers more financial backing this past summer. Hopefully FSG have learned from their mistakes and will be wiser with their investments going forward. The decision to subsequently disband the director of football role is a good indication that they are finally getting their heads around the issues of running a football club especially as a business enterprise.

Follow me on Twitter @superbag

Not a Vital Liverpool member? It's a 100% free to join and get involved. Plus it only takes a few moments to sign up. Click here to become a member now!



Click here to join in the debate on the club forum.

Writer:Gavin Kelley-Day
Date:Friday December 14 2012
Time: 4:18PM

Login to post a comment

Best of Vital Network

Vital Boxing - Adams Turns Professional

Recent Liverpool Articles

Liverpool: The Weekly LFC News Update (24/01/2017)

A selection of Liverpool Football Club-related stories and titbits you may have missed over the past seven days

Deloitte's Money League For 2017

The turn of a New Year means a new edition of Deloitte's Football Money League and analysis of the season just gone.

Liverpool: Lazar Markovic Swaps Lisbon For Hull

Surplus winger Lazar Markovic has left Sporting Lisbon for the less salubrious surrounds of Hull City

Most Expensive Player Values - Jan 2017

The Cies Football Observatory have been crunching their numbers again to produce the January 2017 edition of their highest player transfer values for the top leagues across Europe.

Archived Vital Liverpool Articles

Vital Liverpool articles from

Site Journalists

Gavin Kelley-Day
Editor email
Profile

Current Poll (see more polls)

Who Will Reach The EFL Cup Final?
Suggested By: Editor
Liverpool100%
Southampton0%
ScoopDragon Premier League Network Sites

League Table

# Team P W D L Pts. GD
1 Chelsea 22 18 1 3 55 32
2 Arsenal 22 14 5 3 47 27
3 Spurs 22 13 7 2 46 29
4 Liverpool 22 13 6 3 45 24
5 Man City 22 13 4 5 43 15
6 Man Utd 22 11 8 3 41 12
7 Everton 22 10 6 6 36 10
8 WBA 22 9 5 8 32 2
9 Stoke 22 7 7 8 28 -6
10 West Ham 22 8 4 10 28 -7
11 Southampton 22 7 6 9 27 -4
12 AFC Bournemouth 22 7 5 10 26 -7
13 Burnley 22 8 2 12 26 -9
14 Watford 22 6 6 10 24 -13
15 Leicester City 22 5 6 11 21 -13
16 Middlesbrough 22 4 8 10 20 -7
17 Swansea 22 5 3 14 18 -25
18 Crystal Palace 22 4 4 14 16 -11
19 Hull City 22 4 4 14 16 -27
20 Sunderland 22 4 3 15 15 -22
The Vital Football Members League
Latest F1 News
Latest Vital Boxing News
Vital Football Comment

Recent Liverpool Results (view all)

Liverpool Fixtures (view all)

Jan 25 2017 8:00PM : Southampton (H)
Capital One Cup
Jan 31 2017 8:00PM : Chelsea (H)
Barclays Premier League
Feb 4 2017 3:00PM : Hull City (a)
Barclays Premier League
Feb 11 2017 5:30PM : Tottenham Hotspur (H)
Barclays Premier League
Feb 27 2017 8:00PM : Leicester City (a)
Barclays Premier League
Mar 4 2017 3:00PM : Arsenal (H)
Barclays Premier League

Vital Members League Table

RankNamePoints
1.BigRed837
Write for Vital Football